Today’s 4G is actually NOT 4G

What is 4G?

4G means “Fourth Generation”.

Today’s devices and cellular networks use a mix of third-generation (3G) and late second-generation (2.5G) technologies. Even after a decade of 3G availability, we all know how often that 3G symbol on our iPhones or Androids goes away, replaced with an icon indicating a slower, 2.5G network such as EDGE or GPRS. Certainly, 3G isn’t where it needs to be yet, and now you’re being sold 4G?

So what does 4G really mean?

According to the definition of the standards body, International Telecommunications Union, a 4G network is supposed to deliver at least 100Mbps throughput from a fast-moving vehicle such as a car or train or 1Gbps from a stationary position.

It’s also supposed to abandon the spread spectrum technology used in 3G networks for frequency-division technologies such as OFDMA that basically packetize network traffic much as the Ethernet protocol does for LANs. That way, individual channels aren’t hogged up by individual connections as happens today.

Wait, what? That’s not possible!

Precisely! There are no 4G networks on the market today that do these things. The two standards that are closest to these requirements are LTE-Advanced and WirelessMAN-Advanced, neither of which is anywhere near real-world deployment.

So why do they label it as 4G?

There are 3 technologies that got the 4G label in the carriers’ marketing. They are LTE, WiMax, and HSPA+ with backbone assist. After the ITU said none of these networks qualified as 4G last year, its carrier members quickly twisted arms and got the ITU to claim that “precursor” technologies leading to these standards could use the 4G label. That means LTE and WiMax.

Only LTE and WiMax are backbones to 4G? How about HSPA+?

HSPA+ doesn’t count because it is simply a faster version of the HSPA 3G technology long used by carriers like AT&T, T-Mobile, SingTel, MobileOne, and many others. These carriers claim that combined with a faster backbone network in some locations, HSPA+ speeds can equal those of LTE. That may or may not be true at any specific location, but it doesn’t matter. As carriers move to first “precursor” 4G technologies and then true 4G, 3G technologies are nearly at the end of their capabilities. Today’s faux 4G from these carriers will not fool anyone in a few years.

Enjoy their marketing!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s